Coverage at a glance
Both insurers are Canadian-licensed and offer comprehensive accident-and-illness coverage. They differ most in payout structure, deductible mechanics, and what's available as an add-on.
| Feature | Trupanion | Pets Plus Us |
|---|---|---|
| Reimbursement rate | 90% flat | Multiple tiers available (typically 70%–90%) |
| Annual payout cap | Unlimited | Capped — varies by plan |
| Deductible structure | Per-condition (lifetime) | Annual |
| Wellness / routine care add-on | No | Optional |
| Plan customization | Single core plan | Multiple plan tiers + deductible/reimbursement choices |
| Direct vet pay | Yes (with VetDirect-enabled clinics) | Reimbursement model |
Advertisement
Responsive
Where each one wins
✓ Trupanion shines when…
- You want maximum protection against catastrophic, single-event bills
- You'd rather pay a flat structure than choose between tiers
- Per-condition deductibles favour long-term, chronic conditions
✓ Pets Plus Us shines when…
- You want to customize your plan tier and deductible
- You'd like the option to add wellness/preventive coverage
- Annual deductibles are easier to budget for
The honest verdict
Our Recommendation
For owners focused on hedging against the worst-case bill — major surgery, cancer, long chronic illness — Trupanion's unlimited cap and per-condition deductible structure is hard to beat.
For owners who want flexibility in plan design, optional wellness coverage, and a familiar annual-deductible model, Pets Plus Us is the more configurable option.
Frequently asked questions
Do both cover hereditary and congenital conditions?
Yes, both cover hereditary and congenital conditions on comprehensive policies, provided they weren't diagnosed or showing symptoms before enrollment. Read each policy wording carefully.
Can I switch from Pets Plus Us to Trupanion later?
Yes, but anything diagnosed while on your current policy will likely be excluded as pre-existing on the new one. Choose your long-term insurer early if possible.
Which is better for older pets?
Get a quote from both — Pets Plus Us has more eligibility flexibility for older pets, but pricing varies. Don't assume.