Coverage at a glance
Both insurers are well-established Canadian brands. They differ most in plan customization, payout caps, and how wellness coverage is structured.
| Feature | Petsecure | Pets Plus Us |
|---|---|---|
| Reimbursement rate | 80% standard | Multiple tiers (typically 70%–90%) |
| Annual payout cap | Capped — varies by plan | Capped — varies by plan |
| Deductible structure | Annual | Annual |
| Wellness / routine care add-on | Optional | Optional |
| Plan customization | Streamlined — fewer plan choices | Highly customizable — tiers + deductible + reimbursement |
| Eligibility (older pets) | Generally flexible | Generally flexible |
Advertisement
Responsive
Where each one wins
✓ Petsecure shines when…
- You want a straightforward Canadian comprehensive plan without too many decisions
- You're attracted to a long-standing Canadian provider
- You want wellness coverage as a clear add-on
✓ Pets Plus Us shines when…
- You want to fine-tune your plan to fit a specific monthly budget
- You'd like the flexibility to choose your reimbursement tier
- You're comparing several plan permutations to find the best fit
The honest verdict
Our Recommendation
For owners who want a clean, simple comprehensive policy from a familiar Canadian brand with optional wellness, Petsecure is a solid default choice.
For owners who want to tune the plan precisely — reimbursement rate, deductible, coverage tier — Pets Plus Us offers more configuration options.
Frequently asked questions
Do both cover hereditary and congenital conditions?
Yes, both comprehensive policies cover hereditary and congenital conditions, provided they weren't diagnosed or showing symptoms before enrollment.
Which has a shorter waiting period?
Waiting periods vary by plan and condition type — check each insurer's policy wording. Accident waiting periods are typically shorter than illness waiting periods at both.
Can I keep wellness coverage and drop it later?
Wellness add-ons are typically annual elections on both providers. You can usually adjust at renewal time. Confirm with the insurer directly.